« Domino Effect50 »
NYT op-ed page hosts seven grunts in Iraq who see the counterinsurgency effort there as pointless and doomed to failure, and wonder why the press says its increasingly manageable.
I believe, in the last week or two, some elements of the press have begun reporting that some people feel that way, but I’d suggest these gentlemen may be misrepresenting the extent of that reporting and what is in fact the “surreal” part of the debate. That would be people like the NYT ed board and Obama saying genocide is OK.
They describe a lot of treachery, unreliability and insecurity, which no doubt is an accurate reflection of their experience and perceptions, but also is countered by numerous accounts from other grunts, officers and embeds that describe growing Iraqi force reliability, improved security and a willingness among brave Iraqis to step forward.
The essay is hampered by the use of a lot of multi-syllabic words to describe abstract concepts, not always very well, making it hard to address the points raised and sometimes hard to understand exactly what they are refering to.
Exactly what course the seven grunts counsel is not clear. They say they are ready to stay to complete the mission, and that it is up to Iraqis to force a withdrawal … something violence prone Iraqis clearly have not managed to do. They say the Iraqi forces are not up to the security task, but appear to advise that U.S. forces take a stand off and let the Iraqis sort it out.
Anyway, free country, they have certainly earned their opinions, whatever those may be. I would love to know the back story, how these seven soldiers came together, decided to take this action and ended up in the New York Times. I’d also be interested to see what comes into the NYT op-ed inbox in reaction to it, and what gets printed. The more knowledgeable voices the better, regardless of their point of view. I’m still waiting for the New York Times to start reporting on this war, especially with September upon us. That said, I suppose we be grateful there is some effort by the op-ed page to make up for the news desk’s failure to bring us much of substance from the field at all.
Best to Staff Sgt. Murphy in his recovery, and best to all of them in the field.
Here’s Blackfive, with a lot. Some point-by-point rebuttals, and also a citation of a past negative analysis that proved spectacularly wrong.
Mark at Blogs for Bush notes that these soldiers are offset by other soldiers’ opinions, all of which is informative, but the military isn’t exactly a democracy. He takes them to task on some overbroad generalizations and the conclusion that the ability to walk down a street unhindered is not an improvement.
Carpetbagger calls it “powerful, accurate, reliable stuff.” Not clear what he’s basing that on. Also, “vastly more important” than everything he disagrees with.
Mahablog, in love with what experienced soldiers say. These are the soldiers that should be listened to. Considerably more important and knowledgeable than Petraeus, their boss, who Mahablog shrugs off. Not clear from this whether Mahablog have ever heard any other soldiers say anything.
Juan Cole thinks its a “thoughtful, analytically precise, and informed essay.” I’d agree with the thoughtful and informed parts, within the range of these infantrymen’s personal experience, but I found it a little analytically obtuse. Cole adds, oddly, “We can’t be too grateful for what these guys are doing for us.” I didn’t realize Cole was a big fan of the mission. I agree with his next comment, however, that “The essay is a major part of seeing through their duty to the American people, since in a democracy, for the people to have a clear-eyed view of the situation is essential to informed policy-making.” It may be that … their opinion … and not fighting terrorism in Iraq part, that Cole is grateful for.
Topics: Iraq, media, military
Posted by Jules Crittenden at 8:41 pm on Sunday, August 19, 2007
Leave a Reply
Trackback URL
You must be logged in to post a comment.
zoloft long distance running G Postmessage Propecia Smiley Post accutane timeline
symptoms of zoloft working! Lipitor Congestion lipitor drug cost
prednisone stopped taking side effects; Prozac And Men difference between lexapro and celexa
accutane timeline Clomid Steroids symptoms of zoloft working!
lipitor drug cost Canine Prednisone Side Effects prednisone stopped taking side effects;
difference between lexapro and celexa Subaction Showcomments Propecia Optional Watch accutane timeline
symptoms of zoloft working! Order Propecia Online lipitor drug cost
prednisone stopped taking side effects; Penis Growth Pills difference between lexapro and celexa
accutane timeline Zoloft Paxil Differences symptoms of zoloft working!
cipro and std treatment,
Female Version Of Viagra prednisone stopped taking side effects;
cough and wheezing with lipitor;
U 3312 Viagra Cialis accutane timeline
clomid dosage lutenizing hormone short G Postmessage Cialis Subject Online lipitor drug cost
lipitor is there a generic; Accutane Before After difference between lexapro and celexa
accutane timeline Subaction Showcomments Cialis Archive Watch symptoms of zoloft working!
lipitor drug cost Alternatives To Zoloft prednisone stopped taking side effects;
difference between lexapro and celexa Adding Prozac To Drinking Water accutane timeline
symptoms of zoloft working! Prozac And Percocet lipitor drug cost
lipitor is there a generic; Propecia Baldness difference between lexapro and celexa
accutane timeline Prednisone And Mania symptoms of zoloft working!
lipitor drug cost Prednisone 10 Mg prednisone stopped taking side effects;
difference between lexapro and celexa
Subaction Showcomments Cialis Smile Newest accutane timeline
clomid dosage lutenizing hormone short Side Effectts Of Cipro lipitor drug cost
prednisone stopped taking side effects; Zoloft And Lorazepam difference between lexapro and celexa
accutane timeline Diuretic Lasix symptoms of zoloft working!
lipitor drug cost Prostatitis And Zithromax prednisone stopped taking side effects;
cough and wheezing with lipitor; Medication And Prednisone accutane timeline
symptoms of zoloft working! Levitra Vs Viagra lipitor drug cost
prednisone stopped taking side effects; Generic Lexapro difference between lexapro and celexa
accutane timeline Query Lowest Cialis Price Online symptoms of zoloft working!
lipitor drug cost Buying Nolvadex prednisone stopped taking side effects;
difference between lexapro and celexa G Postmessage Propecia Subject Remember accutane timeline
symptoms of zoloft working! Get Off Prozac lipitor drug cost
prednisone stopped taking side effects; Cialis Vision difference between lexapro and celexa
accutane timeline Prednisone 20mg symptoms of zoloft working!
lipitor drug cost Prozac Dose Side Effect prednisone stopped taking side effects;
difference between lexapro and celexa Is Ultracet Addictive accutane timeline
symptoms of zoloft working! Nexium Canada lipitor drug cost
prednisone stopped taking side effects; Nexium Side Effects difference between lexapro and celexa
accutane timeline Cheapest Cialis symptoms of zoloft working!
cipro and std treatment,
Prozac Weight Gain prednisone stopped taking side effects;
cough and wheezing with lipitor; Cheap Cialis accutane timeline
symptoms of zoloft working! Clomid Side Effects lipitor drug cost
prednisone stopped taking side effects; Treatment Of Ocd With Zoloft difference between lexapro and celexa
accutane timeline Levitra Side Effects symptoms of zoloft working!
cipro and std treatment, What Is Prednisone Used For prednisone stopped taking side effects;
difference between lexapro and celexa
Accutane And Results accutane timeline
clomid dosage lutenizing hormone short Mexican Rx Cialis Low Price lipitor drug cost
lipitor is there a generic; G Postmessage Propecia Smiley Reply difference between lexapro and celexa
accutane timeline Purepac Prednisone symptoms of zoloft working!
cipro and std treatment,
Cialis Effect On Women prednisone stopped taking side effects;
cough and wheezing with lipitor; accutane timeline
clomid dosage lutenizing hormone short Accutane Buy Canada Pharmacy lipitor drug cost
lipitor is there a generic; Herbal Meds Compatible With Clomid difference between lexapro and celexa
accutane timeline Prozac Suicide Class Action Lawsuit symptoms of zoloft working!
lipitor drug cost Prednisone Without Prescription prednisone stopped taking side effects;
difference between lexapro and celexa Cipro For Uti accutane timeline
symptoms of zoloft working! Zoloft Dosage lipitor drug cost
lipitor is there a generic; Cipro Rem Sleep difference between lexapro and celexa
accutane timeline Lexapro Weight Gain symptoms of zoloft working!
lipitor drug cost Bad Side Effects Of Prednisone prednisone stopped taking side effects;
difference between lexapro and celexa Esophageal Achalasia Swallowing Difficulties Nexium accutane timeline
symptoms of zoloft working! Prednisone Poison Oak lipitor drug cost
prednisone stopped taking side effects; Cialis Story difference between lexapro and celexa
accutane timeline Nexium Cost symptoms of zoloft working!
lipitor drug cost Cheap Generic Cialis prednisone stopped taking side effects;
difference between lexapro and celexa Canine Prednisone accutane timeline
symptoms of zoloft working! Resting Heart Rate Lipitor lipitor drug cost
prednisone stopped taking side effects; Manufactor Of Prozac difference between lexapro and celexa
accutane timeline Prednisone Titration symptoms of zoloft working!
lipitor drug cost Prozac And Weight Gain prednisone stopped taking side effects;
difference between lexapro and celexa Nexium Rebate accutane timeline
symptoms of zoloft working! Zithromax Cost lipitor drug cost
prednisone stopped taking side effects; Prednisone For Dogs difference between lexapro and celexa
accutane timeline Cipro Dose Cat symptoms of zoloft working!
lipitor drug cost Symptoms Of Zoloft prednisone stopped taking side effects;
difference between lexapro and celexa Alcohol And Zoloft accutane timeline
symptoms of zoloft working! Subaction Showcomments Cialis Thanks Newest lipitor drug cost
prednisone stopped taking side effects; Drug Interaction Prozac Sulfamethoxazol Trimethoprim difference between lexapro and celexa
accutane timeline Simcor Vs Lipitor symptoms of zoloft working!
lipitor drug cost Akathisia Zoloft prednisone stopped taking side effects;
difference between lexapro and celexa Prednisone Homeopathic Replacement accutane timeline
symptoms of zoloft working! Zoloft Negative Side Effects lipitor drug cost
prednisone stopped taking side effects; Prednisone Homopathic Replacement difference between lexapro and celexa
accutane timeline Lasix Online symptoms of zoloft working!
lipitor drug cost Cialis Overnight prednisone stopped taking side effects;
difference between lexapro and celexa Tadalafil Cialis From India accutane timeline
symptoms of zoloft working! Subaction Showcomments Cialis Thanks Watch lipitor drug cost
prednisone stopped taking side effects; Zoloft Generic difference between lexapro and celexa
accutane timeline Accutane Long Term Side Effects symptoms of zoloft working!
get a prescription for propecia Zoloft Thin Blood prednisone stopped taking side effects;
difference between lexapro and celexa Multiple Sclerosis Lipitor Bad Reaction accutane timeline
symptoms of zoloft working! Clomid Pdr lipitor drug cost
prednisone stopped taking side effects; Zoloft Akathisias difference between lexapro and celexa
accutane timeline Cipro Warnings symptoms of zoloft working!
lipitor drug cost Secret Side Effects Of Zoloft prednisone stopped taking side effects;
difference between lexapro and celexa Prednisone And Blood Pressure accutane timeline
symptoms of zoloft working! New Drug Cialis lipitor drug cost
prednisone stopped taking side effects;
Subaction Showcomments Propecia Archive Newest difference between lexapro and celexa
prednisone menstrual cycle! Side Effects Of Cialis symptoms of zoloft working!
lipitor drug cost Info Levitra prednisone stopped taking side effects;
difference between lexapro and celexa Buy Lasix Without Prescription accutane timeline
symptoms of zoloft working! Cialis For Order lipitor drug cost
prednisone stopped taking side effects; Buspar Zoloft difference between lexapro and celexa
accutane timeline Prednisone Information symptoms of zoloft working!
lipitor drug cost prednisone stopped taking side effects;
cough and wheezing with lipitor; Lipitor Instructions Side Effects accutane timeline
symptoms of zoloft working! Cialis Injury Lawyer Ohio lipitor drug cost
prednisone stopped taking side effects; Zoloft Side Effects difference between lexapro and celexa
accutane timeline Weaning Off Prednisone symptoms of zoloft working!
cipro and std treatment,
Prozac Side Affects prednisone stopped taking side effects;
cough and wheezing with lipitor; Cialis Faq accutane timeline
symptoms of zoloft working! Zoloft With Wellbutrin lipitor drug cost
lipitor is there a generic; Lexapro Withdrawal difference between lexapro and celexa
clomid with triplets Cialis 20mg symptoms of zoloft working!
lipitor drug cost Atavan And Prozac prednisone stopped taking side effects;
difference between lexapro and celexa Prozac Long Term Use accutane timeline
symptoms of zoloft working! Prednisone Tremors lipitor drug cost
prednisone stopped taking side effects; Accutane Attorneys California difference between lexapro and celexa
clomid with triplets Levitra Medicine symptoms of zoloft working!
lipitor drug cost Lipitor And Muscle Pain prednisone stopped taking side effects;
difference between lexapro and celexa
How Does Cialis Work accutane timeline
clomid dosage lutenizing hormone short Stopping Zoloft lipitor drug cost
lipitor is there a generic; Side Effects Lexapro difference between lexapro and celexa
accutane timeline Prednisone Dogs Shrink Tumor symptoms of zoloft working!
lipitor drug cost India Viagra Cialis Vicodin prednisone stopped taking side effects;
difference between lexapro and celexa
Buy Cialis In The Uk accutane timeline
clomid dosage lutenizing hormone short Cialis Lawyer Ohio lipitor drug cost
lipitor is there a generic; Average Dose For Zoloft difference between lexapro and celexa
accutane timeline Zoloft Overdose symptoms of zoloft working!
lipitor drug cost Snorting Lexapro prednisone stopped taking side effects;
cough and wheezing with lipitor; Buy Clomid Online accutane timeline
symptoms of zoloft working! Atlanta Accutane Law Suits lipitor drug cost
August 20th, 2007 at 3:39 am
I’ve read the article, and Grim’s assessment at Blackfive (along with the comments, which were just as interesting). Juan Cole could not interest me no matter what the subject.
I appreciate the information and assessment in the NYT’s article. I’ve heard it before from Marines returning from Iraq. I even agree with some of it, and find parts of it important to the discussion. I also know that such opinions about operations among the troops are not unusual in the middle of a war. All one need do is read the letters and diaries of Civil War soldiers, for instance, to understand this. There are such letters and diaries from Grant’s soldiers sitting through the hell of the Vicksburg siege that question Grant’s sanity and competency. Who could blame them? This is the reason that articles written during such times are not allowed–or at least, did not used to be allowed. (It’s not my military, just as my military wasn’t my father’s, or his, his father’s.)
If you haven’t read Grim’s post at Blackfive, I recommend that you do (as well as the comments). As one sitting in the comfort of my home, I can only hope that his assessment is correct. We have put ourselves in a Catch 22 situation in this war–and we cannot afford to lose. Civilization cannot afford to lose.
August 20th, 2007 at 7:03 am
I knew a man who survived a Japanese POW camp in the Philippines and he thought MacArthur and FDR should have been shot for leaving them there to die. He saw thousands die. I don’t think most of the military felt that way, but his experiences shaped him.
A person’s individual experiences are valid, but there is a lot of variation to those opinions and I am sure that there are a half dozen guys who could tell you a completely different story about Iraq.
August 20th, 2007 at 11:41 am
All through the late 90’s and into 2003 these people told us Saddam was a juggernaut who had to be stopped. He was a terror enabler, he had weapons, he would use them, besides, the UN sanctions were killing 5000 Iraqi children a month, blah, blah, blah. Regime change in Iraq was a policy crafted and adopted by the Clinton administration. They did not tell us how difficult that would be, only Bush and the neocons did that. Sensing a path back to political relevancy, they fell out of love with the idea and since then we have had an entire string of fabulist lefty “war heroes” (Kerry, McBeth, Beauchamp, and others) tell us that the whole enterprise is a crock and their comrades (our brothers, sons, uncles and fathers) are a bunch of war criminals for going along with it. They even conjured up the old “whiz kid” Robert McNamara to write a book telling us the Vietnam War was a hug mistake and if he had to do it again, he would be much more in tune with the current McGovernite Democrat Party. (It would be nice if 58,000 infantrymen and aviators were waiting for you up there Mr. Secretary to let you know what they thought of your book, but I’m rather hoping you aren’t going where they are). So when does approximately half the country start questioning these people on the issue of National Security, because they have less than zero credibility.
/rant
August 20th, 2007 at 12:02 pm
“82nd Airborne…Near End of 15th month deployment” places them in Salahadin.
The June report to congress listed Salahadin as the second most violent province. Per-Capita it is the most violent province.
August 21st, 2007 at 4:07 pm
VotC, roger on the “but I’m rather hoping you aren’t going where they are.”
September 8th, 2007 at 8:42 am
Eric
I dont agree with you, if you look in Google you will see that your wrong.