« Dumpster Diving For Hidden TreasuresPaul Sullivan, 1957-2007 »
This UCLA/NYU study says lefties and righties think differently. Open-minded lefties, rigid righties use different parts of their brains. Righties, has it happens, get it wrong more. Lefties enlightened, righties … troglodytes.
Frank J. Sulloway, a researcher at UC Berkeley’s Institute of Personality and Social Research who was not connected to the study, said the results “provided an elegant demonstration that individual differences on a conservative-liberal dimension are strongly related to brain activity.”
Analyzing the data, Sulloway said liberals were 4.9 times as likely as conservatives to show activity in the brain circuits that deal with conflicts, and 2.2 times as likely to score in the top half of the distribution for accuracy.
Sulloway said the results could explain why President Bush demonstrated a single-minded commitment to the Iraq war and why some people perceived Sen. John F. Kerry, the liberal Massachusetts Democrat who opposed Bush in the 2004 presidential race, as a “flip-flopper” for changing his mind about the conflict.
Actually, that was because they saw him as a mountebank and a shameless political opportunist, to put it politely, with a history of checking the wind direction and jumping on and off bandwagons, particularly when the going got tough. But that’s a separate issue.
The study was done among college students. I’d throw out all results on that basis alone. We’re talking about immature people for whom being open to everything is a rigid position, and for whom rigidity represents a form of nonconformity. Study also does not address actual reaction to life experience, which can turn lefties into righties and righties into lefties.
But at the risk of being considered open-minded, I’ll say these are interesting results. But a little too rigid. Let’s make it more interesting. Open it up a little. I’d like to see how it breaks down among, say, union autoworkers and Wall Street executives. Cuban government officials and GOP campaign volunteers. Heck, let’s go all the way. What’s the most progressive country in the world? North Korea! What country is the right-wing den of capitalist evil? Us! Let’s do North Korean party members vs. American Imperialist Running Dogs.
I’d also like to know if having an open mind is more likely to make you trend conservative with age and experience, and if having a rigid one is likely to make you turn left. Let’s see some questionnaires and brainscans on the same people 20 or 30 years from now.
Surber no understand big words.
Welcome PJM, Surberistas, etal! Stay in cave. Enjoy Ugh’s boneheaded hospitality:
Dumpster Diving for Hidden Treasures
Rock Garden Press Conference
Topics: other
Posted by Jules Crittenden at 10:15 am on Monday, September 10, 2007
Leave a Reply
Trackback URL
You must be logged in to post a comment.
zoloft long distance running G Postmessage Propecia Smiley Post accutane timeline
symptoms of zoloft working! Lipitor Congestion lipitor drug cost
prednisone stopped taking side effects; Prozac And Men difference between lexapro and celexa
accutane timeline Clomid Steroids symptoms of zoloft working!
lipitor drug cost Canine Prednisone Side Effects prednisone stopped taking side effects;
difference between lexapro and celexa Subaction Showcomments Propecia Optional Watch accutane timeline
symptoms of zoloft working! Order Propecia Online lipitor drug cost
prednisone stopped taking side effects; Penis Growth Pills difference between lexapro and celexa
accutane timeline Zoloft Paxil Differences symptoms of zoloft working!
cipro and std treatment,
Female Version Of Viagra prednisone stopped taking side effects;
cough and wheezing with lipitor;
U 3312 Viagra Cialis accutane timeline
clomid dosage lutenizing hormone short G Postmessage Cialis Subject Online lipitor drug cost
lipitor is there a generic; Accutane Before After difference between lexapro and celexa
accutane timeline Subaction Showcomments Cialis Archive Watch symptoms of zoloft working!
lipitor drug cost Alternatives To Zoloft prednisone stopped taking side effects;
difference between lexapro and celexa Adding Prozac To Drinking Water accutane timeline
symptoms of zoloft working! Prozac And Percocet lipitor drug cost
lipitor is there a generic; Propecia Baldness difference between lexapro and celexa
accutane timeline Prednisone And Mania symptoms of zoloft working!
lipitor drug cost Prednisone 10 Mg prednisone stopped taking side effects;
difference between lexapro and celexa
Subaction Showcomments Cialis Smile Newest accutane timeline
clomid dosage lutenizing hormone short Side Effectts Of Cipro lipitor drug cost
prednisone stopped taking side effects; Zoloft And Lorazepam difference between lexapro and celexa
accutane timeline Diuretic Lasix symptoms of zoloft working!
lipitor drug cost Prostatitis And Zithromax prednisone stopped taking side effects;
cough and wheezing with lipitor; Medication And Prednisone accutane timeline
symptoms of zoloft working! Levitra Vs Viagra lipitor drug cost
prednisone stopped taking side effects; Generic Lexapro difference between lexapro and celexa
accutane timeline Query Lowest Cialis Price Online symptoms of zoloft working!
lipitor drug cost Buying Nolvadex prednisone stopped taking side effects;
difference between lexapro and celexa G Postmessage Propecia Subject Remember accutane timeline
symptoms of zoloft working! Get Off Prozac lipitor drug cost
prednisone stopped taking side effects; Cialis Vision difference between lexapro and celexa
accutane timeline Prednisone 20mg symptoms of zoloft working!
lipitor drug cost Prozac Dose Side Effect prednisone stopped taking side effects;
difference between lexapro and celexa Is Ultracet Addictive accutane timeline
symptoms of zoloft working! Nexium Canada lipitor drug cost
prednisone stopped taking side effects; Nexium Side Effects difference between lexapro and celexa
accutane timeline Cheapest Cialis symptoms of zoloft working!
cipro and std treatment,
Prozac Weight Gain prednisone stopped taking side effects;
cough and wheezing with lipitor; Cheap Cialis accutane timeline
symptoms of zoloft working! Clomid Side Effects lipitor drug cost
prednisone stopped taking side effects; Treatment Of Ocd With Zoloft difference between lexapro and celexa
accutane timeline Levitra Side Effects symptoms of zoloft working!
cipro and std treatment, What Is Prednisone Used For prednisone stopped taking side effects;
difference between lexapro and celexa
Accutane And Results accutane timeline
clomid dosage lutenizing hormone short Mexican Rx Cialis Low Price lipitor drug cost
lipitor is there a generic; G Postmessage Propecia Smiley Reply difference between lexapro and celexa
accutane timeline Purepac Prednisone symptoms of zoloft working!
cipro and std treatment,
Cialis Effect On Women prednisone stopped taking side effects;
cough and wheezing with lipitor; accutane timeline
clomid dosage lutenizing hormone short Accutane Buy Canada Pharmacy lipitor drug cost
lipitor is there a generic; Herbal Meds Compatible With Clomid difference between lexapro and celexa
accutane timeline Prozac Suicide Class Action Lawsuit symptoms of zoloft working!
lipitor drug cost Prednisone Without Prescription prednisone stopped taking side effects;
difference between lexapro and celexa Cipro For Uti accutane timeline
symptoms of zoloft working! Zoloft Dosage lipitor drug cost
lipitor is there a generic; Cipro Rem Sleep difference between lexapro and celexa
accutane timeline Lexapro Weight Gain symptoms of zoloft working!
lipitor drug cost Bad Side Effects Of Prednisone prednisone stopped taking side effects;
difference between lexapro and celexa Esophageal Achalasia Swallowing Difficulties Nexium accutane timeline
symptoms of zoloft working! Prednisone Poison Oak lipitor drug cost
prednisone stopped taking side effects; Cialis Story difference between lexapro and celexa
accutane timeline Nexium Cost symptoms of zoloft working!
lipitor drug cost Cheap Generic Cialis prednisone stopped taking side effects;
difference between lexapro and celexa Canine Prednisone accutane timeline
symptoms of zoloft working! Resting Heart Rate Lipitor lipitor drug cost
prednisone stopped taking side effects; Manufactor Of Prozac difference between lexapro and celexa
accutane timeline Prednisone Titration symptoms of zoloft working!
lipitor drug cost Prozac And Weight Gain prednisone stopped taking side effects;
difference between lexapro and celexa Nexium Rebate accutane timeline
symptoms of zoloft working! Zithromax Cost lipitor drug cost
prednisone stopped taking side effects; Prednisone For Dogs difference between lexapro and celexa
accutane timeline Cipro Dose Cat symptoms of zoloft working!
lipitor drug cost Symptoms Of Zoloft prednisone stopped taking side effects;
difference between lexapro and celexa Alcohol And Zoloft accutane timeline
symptoms of zoloft working! Subaction Showcomments Cialis Thanks Newest lipitor drug cost
prednisone stopped taking side effects; Drug Interaction Prozac Sulfamethoxazol Trimethoprim difference between lexapro and celexa
accutane timeline Simcor Vs Lipitor symptoms of zoloft working!
lipitor drug cost Akathisia Zoloft prednisone stopped taking side effects;
difference between lexapro and celexa Prednisone Homeopathic Replacement accutane timeline
symptoms of zoloft working! Zoloft Negative Side Effects lipitor drug cost
prednisone stopped taking side effects; Prednisone Homopathic Replacement difference between lexapro and celexa
accutane timeline Lasix Online symptoms of zoloft working!
lipitor drug cost Cialis Overnight prednisone stopped taking side effects;
difference between lexapro and celexa Tadalafil Cialis From India accutane timeline
symptoms of zoloft working! Subaction Showcomments Cialis Thanks Watch lipitor drug cost
prednisone stopped taking side effects; Zoloft Generic difference between lexapro and celexa
accutane timeline Accutane Long Term Side Effects symptoms of zoloft working!
get a prescription for propecia Zoloft Thin Blood prednisone stopped taking side effects;
difference between lexapro and celexa Multiple Sclerosis Lipitor Bad Reaction accutane timeline
symptoms of zoloft working! Clomid Pdr lipitor drug cost
prednisone stopped taking side effects; Zoloft Akathisias difference between lexapro and celexa
accutane timeline Cipro Warnings symptoms of zoloft working!
lipitor drug cost Secret Side Effects Of Zoloft prednisone stopped taking side effects;
difference between lexapro and celexa Prednisone And Blood Pressure accutane timeline
symptoms of zoloft working! New Drug Cialis lipitor drug cost
prednisone stopped taking side effects;
Subaction Showcomments Propecia Archive Newest difference between lexapro and celexa
prednisone menstrual cycle! Side Effects Of Cialis symptoms of zoloft working!
lipitor drug cost Info Levitra prednisone stopped taking side effects;
difference between lexapro and celexa Buy Lasix Without Prescription accutane timeline
symptoms of zoloft working! Cialis For Order lipitor drug cost
prednisone stopped taking side effects; Buspar Zoloft difference between lexapro and celexa
accutane timeline Prednisone Information symptoms of zoloft working!
lipitor drug cost prednisone stopped taking side effects;
cough and wheezing with lipitor; Lipitor Instructions Side Effects accutane timeline
symptoms of zoloft working! Cialis Injury Lawyer Ohio lipitor drug cost
prednisone stopped taking side effects; Zoloft Side Effects difference between lexapro and celexa
accutane timeline Weaning Off Prednisone symptoms of zoloft working!
cipro and std treatment,
Prozac Side Affects prednisone stopped taking side effects;
cough and wheezing with lipitor; Cialis Faq accutane timeline
symptoms of zoloft working! Zoloft With Wellbutrin lipitor drug cost
lipitor is there a generic; Lexapro Withdrawal difference between lexapro and celexa
clomid with triplets Cialis 20mg symptoms of zoloft working!
lipitor drug cost Atavan And Prozac prednisone stopped taking side effects;
difference between lexapro and celexa Prozac Long Term Use accutane timeline
symptoms of zoloft working! Prednisone Tremors lipitor drug cost
prednisone stopped taking side effects; Accutane Attorneys California difference between lexapro and celexa
clomid with triplets Levitra Medicine symptoms of zoloft working!
lipitor drug cost Lipitor And Muscle Pain prednisone stopped taking side effects;
difference between lexapro and celexa
How Does Cialis Work accutane timeline
clomid dosage lutenizing hormone short Stopping Zoloft lipitor drug cost
lipitor is there a generic; Side Effects Lexapro difference between lexapro and celexa
accutane timeline Prednisone Dogs Shrink Tumor symptoms of zoloft working!
lipitor drug cost India Viagra Cialis Vicodin prednisone stopped taking side effects;
difference between lexapro and celexa
Buy Cialis In The Uk accutane timeline
clomid dosage lutenizing hormone short Cialis Lawyer Ohio lipitor drug cost
lipitor is there a generic; Average Dose For Zoloft difference between lexapro and celexa
accutane timeline Zoloft Overdose symptoms of zoloft working!
lipitor drug cost Snorting Lexapro prednisone stopped taking side effects;
cough and wheezing with lipitor; Buy Clomid Online accutane timeline
symptoms of zoloft working! Atlanta Accutane Law Suits lipitor drug cost
September 10th, 2007 at 11:47 am
Study: Conservatives More Mistake-Prone And Show Less Brain Activity Than Liberals When Exposed To The Letter “W”
Liberals are open-minded “flip-floppers” and conservatives are mindless, “knee-jerk” drones according to a study conducted by scientists from New York University and UCLA:
Study finds left-wing brain, right-wing brain
Even in hu…
September 10th, 2007 at 12:12 pm
Open-minded lefties, rigid righties use different parts of their brains.
Then I really had a profound change in how I think when I shifted from liberal to conservative views over the years. Yes, I used to be a old-fashioned liberal (not one of these newfangled “progressives” or “neo-liberal”).
Which, if one takes this study seriously, implies that brain activity is not static. Which, in turn, implies that some of the studies premises are invalid, let alone the results, even ignoring the population segment the study targeted*.
=====================================
*: College students?!?!?!?!?! Before or after weekend binge parties?
September 10th, 2007 at 12:21 pm
They found conservatives on the campuses of UCLA and NYU? How?
September 10th, 2007 at 12:47 pm
[...] THE ASTUTE BLOGGERS, The Moderate Voice, Jules Crittenden, Shakespeare’s Sister, DownWithTyranny!, The Mahablog, The Gun Toting Liberal™, Althouse, [...]
September 10th, 2007 at 1:17 pm
[...] 10th, 2007 by Michael van der Galiën Enough already. We get it: conservatives are stupid and stubborn. The LA Times has an article up about a recently [...]
September 10th, 2007 at 1:31 pm
Yup. This explains why all the new ideas are on the “rigid” Right these days, and the “open minded” Left keeps flogging the same redistributionist crap that has been failing spectacularly since, heck, 1848.
September 10th, 2007 at 2:12 pm
I know! Let’s do a study on left-wing academic hacks and see if the results show them to be rigidly ideological gasbags who wouldn’t recognize a new idea if it hit them in the smackeroo.
September 10th, 2007 at 2:35 pm
Me no understand.
Too many big words.
Ugh.
Me no like.
September 10th, 2007 at 4:58 pm
ugga ugga grunt grunt.
September 10th, 2007 at 5:31 pm
[...] no understand LA Times story on conservative vs. liberal brains. Too many big words. Friend Jules, him understand. Law woman, Ann, her understand. Me, no [...]
September 10th, 2007 at 6:55 pm
I’m left handed, and INTJ personality type. My whole life I’ve been able to visualize viable solutions to technical and mechanical problems that others struggle with terribly.
Lefty’s do see the world differently.
I’ll often look at something a righty is trying to do and just intuitively know “that’s not going to work” because I just know its not going to work. They always get miffed of course and continue the failing path for a few hours/days/weeks. They can’t understand how I can sort of “flash comprehend” their problem in its totality.
September 10th, 2007 at 7:00 pm
Look, there was some skewed study out of Berzerkley a few years ago that said conservatives are all fascists, or something like that.
Ohmygod, Frank Sulloway (cited above) is the author of that study.
http://www.worldnetdaily.com/news/article.asp?ARTICLE_ID=33714
September 10th, 2007 at 7:09 pm
“academic researchers” are such dorks.
Given the dorki-tude of their own private lives, how DARE they purport to understanding/analyze anything.
Here is representational evidence of the only brain differences that MEAN anything :-)
(it’s a joke people, lighten up)
http://gregladen.com/wordpress/?p=839
September 10th, 2007 at 11:36 pm
I suppose that if it were the case that homo sapiens operate at the perceptual level, this hogwash might work. Since homo sapiens are conceptual beings, by virtue of the rational faculty, this is alas nothing but hogwash, perpetrated by not-fully-formed specimens of homo sapiens who attempt to run the world by the pseudo-scientific use of their feelings and “instincts”. It causes them to interpret data in the silliest, and incredibly shallow, ways. This is the predictable result of conceptual beings trying to act like an animal that lives on the level of percepts. I sometimes think this must be the reason why this type also puts so much store in what children have to say. There are those who seem to believe that childish innocence–borne of inexperience with reality–is graced by some special kind of wisdom. I suppose if you never rise to the conceptual level of an adult, you might have a stake in the sagacity of children.
I would like to ask the professor if he knows the difference between an open mind, you know–like a garbage dump that takes anything–and an rational adult’s critical mind. As an adult, with an adult’s experience with life, there are many ideas that I’ve already grappled with and come to this or that conclusion. Unless I find credible evidence that I’ve erred in my conclusion, I don’t waste my time going over old ground. Tell me the last time you heard anything new come out of these sociology labs? I bet the only thing that might possibly surprise folks would be the amount of grant money that is pored into this quackery standing in for scholarship. It speaks to why the “open-minded” acceptance sans any objective standard (”bias,” “bigotry,” and the now thoroughly corrupted discrimination, in newspeak) is so damned important. The first requirement for them to get away with this sort of thing is for there not to be any standards by which to form judgments–and more, that any sort of standard be perceived as morally suspect.
September 11th, 2007 at 12:10 am
Unless I find credible evidence that I’ve erred in my conclusion, I don’t waste my time going over old ground.
“wisdom” is born of a lifetime of failure and correction. The young haven’t failed enough to become wise yet.
September 11th, 2007 at 10:48 am
This study should actually show how a very simple test can be used to jump to many interesting, but unsupported conclusions. All the test showed was that “liberals” are better than “conservatives” at a rote visual identification procedure. An alternate interpretation could be that liberals are better at following rigid procedures without deviation and are admirably suited for tasks such as quality control at a dry bean processing plant removing the malformed beans. Personally, I have trouble seeing that the results indicate a greater toleration for ambiguity on the part of the liberal rather it would seem to indicate a greater toleration for rote obedience of an essentially boring task.
September 11th, 2007 at 11:29 am
“I have trouble seeing that the results indicate a greater toleration for ambiguity on the part of the liberal rather it would seem to indicate a greater toleration for rote obedience of an essentially boring task.”
That too. I reacted too quickly to even get to the “substance” (what substance ?) of the conclusions.
There is way too much pseudoscience about nowadays (”scientism”) where the conclusions drawn are a function of the agenda held at the outset of “the study”.
Such debates–more about politics and personal agenda than science, of course– dominate the “global warming” discussion.
Anyway, as for the “liberal” brain, I (anyway) am convinced it has few functioning actual neurons :-) and is (in the words of repentant British liberal Andrew Anthony) quite threatened at the idea of abandoning any portion of the wholecloth mantra, the individual’s “identity” being all tied up with the worldview.